Long live Horatio Alger, the Congress said yesterday.  The Senate Finance Committee, by its vote against a public option in health reform legislation,  told the American people  that  if you can’t be Horatio Alger–if you can’t suffer and persevere and make it on your own when it comes to health care– tough luck.  Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus lives too much on the frontier.  He  obviously still believes in the Horatio Alger myth–that is,  that America can be sustained by  rugged individuals who, like the boys glorified by the 19th century dime-store novelist  Horatio Alger,  can go from rags to riches on their own solely by hard work and clean living. 

Without a public option, Baucus is saying that if you get sick, don’t have a job, lost your job, can’t pay your bills, get insurance coverage, figure out the insurance system, there must be something  wrong with you.  You’re not living right. You didn’t follow the Alger rules. The government will not help you.

 Shame on Senator Max Baucus. Shame on the Finance Committee. Shame on President Obama for letting the Congress act on its own on health care.  Shame on  America for not protesting in favor of a public option.

 This is the 21st Century.  Horatio Alger is not the role model we should be admiring. Did Horatio get an inherited form of cancer? Did Horatio lose his job because thieves on Wall Street were “too big to fail?”  There are forces at work beyond the control of any one person.  No one can make it on his  own these days—and no one should be blamed for that.

Horatio Alger  can no more protect his health in the modern world than he can provide for his own defense with a musket in the corner of his room in the boarding house!

 The government should protect its people with a health care program just as Horatio Alger –in the end– was saved from poverty with the help of a wealthy benefactor.